How to Rent by Owner in Orlando

You’ve just bought an investment home in Orlando and are looking into making it a long-term rental home. Where do you start? How do you qualify long-term rental applicants and find the good ones?

If you’re serious about managing and renting your house direct to tenants, you must keep up to date with Florida Landlord and Tenant laws. If you need any assistance, you can reach out to our South Orlando property management company and we’ll do our best to answer your questions.

From our experience: Anne-Marie McCormack has been a Florida real estate broker since 1996. At McCormack Realty and Renters Choice Homes, we work with owners based in other US states, Canada and the UK. Many came to us after finding their vacation rentals were not covering their costs, and we helped them transition to long-term rentals.

First, What Does It Mean to Rent By Owner

Renting by owner means the property owner directly manages all aspects of the rental process without involving a property management company. This includes advertising the property, screening tenants, drafting leases, collecting rent, and handling maintenance or repairs. It allows you to save on property management fees but requires significant time and effort.

What to Ask When You Rent By Owner In Orlando

You’ll need to know what to look for when interviewing applicants, so here are some of the things we look for when interviewing long-term rental applicants:

  • Use a viewing to explain the property and published application process, not to judge whether people seem like a personal fit. Give applicants the same documented, lawful criteria and assess verified information consistently.
  • If they’re interested in leasing your home and they wish to apply, get signed consent from all the applicants to order their credit, background, and employment verification. You should order these reports from the leading credit agencies after they have viewed your home. Reports can be incomplete or inaccurate and do not establish every past event or predict future conduct. Confirm that records match the applicant and use only relevant information under legally reviewed criteria; do not assume a nationwide check is exhaustive. The FTC’s Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know explains that a decision based even partly on a consumer report can require an adverse-action notice, including the reporting agency’s contact details, a statement that it did not make the decision, and the applicant’s rights to dispute errors and request a free report within 60 days. Credit-score use can trigger additional disclosures. Confirm permissible purpose and applicable consent requirements before ordering reports, protect the information, and have a qualified housing-law professional review your screening and notice process.
  • Ask for personal references and call all the supplied references to ask about the applicants. You want to ensure your potential tenant is trustworthy for a long-term rental.
  • Verify the prospect’s employment and income by looking at their pay stubs for the last couple of months, calling the employer’s HR department, and verifying the income and jobs are stable.

Don’t rent sight unseen; be upfront about your expectations with potential long-term rental applicants.

  • Talk to their previous landlord, ask whether they pay on time, and take good care of the home. Would you rerent to them?
  • Do not approve or reject applicants on a gut feeling, personal similarity or an undefined right-fit test. If information is missing or inconsistent, document the specific issue, offer the same opportunity to clarify it, and decide against the written, lawful criteria. Keep the factual decision record and provide any required notices.
  • If you’re doing this yourself, here’s where you can view our application online to get an idea of the questions to put on your application. Click here and check our “Rental Application” for ideas of what to ask applicants.
  • Is the rent affordable – a good rule of thumb is their net pay should be at least three times the rent? Ask to see the last two months of their paystubs; if they are self-employed, ask to see the previous two years of their tax returns.
  • Explain the property’s actual, legally reviewed pet policy rather than inventing a universal weight or insurance requirement. Confirm association and insurer conditions and provide a process for disability-related accommodation requests; assistance-animal requests need separate review rather than automatic application of ordinary pet restrictions or fees. Ask a qualified housing-law adviser how the requirements apply before making a decision.
  • Did everything check out ok, or did they lie? If they lied on the application, they wouldn’t make good tenants. It’s best to start with honesty when considering a long-term rental contract.
  • Check your HOA rules for parking and vehicle restrictions and ensure the tenant’s vehicles will be ok with the HOA rules. It may also be helpful to ask if they plan to work on cars at the residence. Some long-term rental tenants will slowly bring more and more vehicles onto the property, potentially causing an HOA issue.
  • Before collecting holding funds, have a Florida landlord-tenant attorney review a written agreement identifying what the payment is for, the holding period, how it will be applied, and the lawful refund or forfeiture conditions if either side does not proceed. Give the applicant the terms before payment and issue a receipt. Do not assume calling a payment nonrefundable makes it so, or confuse holding funds with the security deposit.
  • Check their ID and ensure the applicants want to live in your home. Sometimes parents will apply and think it’s ok to be on the lease with their grown-up children, but not live there. Tell them you’re only running applications on people who will be living there.
  • Don’t take regular checks or cash when asking for security deposits and rent-holding funds. These should be paid by cashier’s check, bank wire, or money orders.
  • Decide how they will pay the ongoing monthly rent payments and set it up for them.

The final decision is always yours; you don’t have to say yes to long-term rental applicants that don’t match your criteria.

Additional Tips for Renting by Owner in Orlando

Beyond the basics, implementing these expanded tips can help you manage your rental property effectively and avoid common pitfalls.


1. Set Competitive Rental Rates

Proper pricing attracts tenants while ensuring your property remains profitable.

  • Research Local Market Trends: Check similar properties in Orlando to gauge market rates. Use online platforms like Zillow or Apartments.com to analyze comparable rentals in your area.
  • Adjust Seasonally: Orlando’s rental demand can fluctuate based on tourism and seasonal trends. Stay flexible to avoid long vacancies.
  • Offer Incentives if Needed: To compete in slower periods, consider perks like reduced security deposits or including utilities in the rent.

2. Create a Detailed Lease Agreement

A well-crafted lease agreement protects your rights and sets clear expectations for tenants.

  • Include Specific Rules: Outline policies regarding late payments, maintenance responsibilities, and use of common areas.
  • Tailor to Florida Laws: Ensure your lease complies with Florida’s landlord-tenant regulations. Include clauses for eviction procedures, notice periods, and security deposit handling.
  • Consider a Legal Review: Consult a real estate attorney to review the document for enforceability and completeness.

3. Conduct Thorough Tenant Screenings

Careful tenant selection minimizes risks of non-payment or property damage.

  • Run Background Checks: Look for criminal history, eviction records, and financial stability.
  • Verify References: Speak with previous landlords to understand the tenant’s behavior and payment history.
  • Check Income-to-Rent Ratio: Confirm the tenant’s income is at least three times the rent amount to ensure affordability.

4. Market the Property Effectively

Attracting high-quality tenants starts with excellent marketing.

  • Use High-Quality Photos: Highlight the property’s best features with well-lit images.
  • Write a Compelling Listing: Include essential details like rent amount, amenities, and proximity to attractions or schools in Orlando.
  • Leverage Multiple Platforms: Advertise on websites like Zillow, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace to reach a broad audience.

5. Stay Informed on Landlord-Tenant Laws

Knowledge of local regulations safeguards against potential disputes.

  • Understand Florida’s Laws: Familiarize yourself with state requirements for security deposits, rent increases, and notice periods.
  • Keep Up with Changes: Laws can evolve, so regularly review updates to ensure compliance.
  • Document Everything: Maintain detailed records of communications, payments, and any legal notices sent to tenants.

6. Maintain Open Communication

Strong tenant relationships lead to smoother property management.

  • Provide Clear Contact Methods: Offer multiple ways for tenants to reach you, such as phone, email, or a dedicated portal.
  • Respond Quickly: Address tenant concerns promptly to foster trust and prevent small issues from escalating.
  • Set Expectations Early: Discuss communication preferences during lease signing, so tenants know when and how to reach you.

7. Prepare for Maintenance and Repairs

Well-maintained properties retain value and attract quality tenants.

  • Build a Reliable Vendor Network: Establish relationships with local contractors and handymen for quick repairs.
  • Budget for Emergencies: Keep funds aside for unexpected repairs like plumbing issues or appliance breakdowns.
  • Schedule Preventive Maintenance: Regularly service HVAC systems, check for leaks, and inspect the property to prevent costly problems.

8. Leverage Technology

Modern tools simplify self-management and improve tenant satisfaction.

  • Use Online Payment Platforms: Services like Rentec Direct or Buildium streamline rent collection and reduce late payments.
  • Set Up Maintenance Portals: Allow tenants to submit repair requests online, making tracking and addressing issues easier.
  • Automate Reminders: Use software to send rent due dates or lease renewal notices automatically.

9. Keep the Property Tenant-Ready

A clean and inviting rental attracts better tenants and ensures smooth transitions between occupants.

  • Thoroughly Clean Between Tenants: Hire professional cleaners to make the property spotless before showings.
  • Address Wear and Tear: Repaint walls, steam clean carpets, and fix minor damages to present a well-maintained home.
  • Stage for Showings: If possible, lightly furnish the property or use virtual staging tools to highlight its potential.

10. Establish a Reserve Fund

Financial preparedness ensures you can handle unexpected situations.

  • Save for Vacancies: Set aside funds to cover mortgage payments and expenses during periods without tenants.
  • Plan for Major Repairs: Large expenses like roof replacements or appliance upgrades can arise suddenly. A reserve fund prevents financial strain.
  • Separate Business Finances: Keep rental income and expenses in a dedicated account for easier tracking and budgeting.

By integrating these strategies, you can successfully manage your Orlando property as a “rent by owner” landlord while maximizing profitability and minimizing stress.

If all of this seems a bit much and you’d instead hire a property manager to do all this for you, don’t hesitate to contact us. We have 35+ years of experience in property management and can always lend a hand.

Frequently Asked Questions About Renting by Owner in Orlando

What should I prepare before publishing a rent-by-owner listing?

Confirm the home is ready, check applicable leasing restrictions and decide on a realistic asking rent. Prepare accurate photographs, written application criteria and a clear contact process. It is easier to manage inquiries when the basics are settled first.

How much should I keep available for rental property repairs?

Base your reserve on the home’s condition, major systems and expected expenses. A general percentage is only a planning aid. A property with older equipment may need more cash available than one with recently replaced systems.

What records should a self-managing owner keep?

Keep the signed lease, application and screening records, deposit documentation, rent ledger, notices, inspection photographs and repair invoices. Store sensitive information securely. Organized records make it easier to answer questions and hand the property over if management arrangements change.

For more detail, see our guide to “Tenant Screening”.

Anne-Marie McCormack
Anne-Marie McCormack

Anne-Marie McCormack has been a licensed Florida Real Estate Broker since 1996 and has worked as a licensed real estate agent in property management, rentals, and residential sales throughout Kissimmee, Davenport, Orlando, and the surrounding Central Florida communities since 1991.

As the head of McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes, Anne-Marie brings more than three decades of hands-on experience working with residential homeowners, investors, vacation-home owners, and out-of-state clients.

From 1994 to 2004, Anne-Marie owned and operated a successful short-term rental and property management company. This first-hand experience gives her a valuable understanding of the opportunities and challenges involved in owning and managing vacation homes, also known as holiday lets.

Today, McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes specializes in long-term property management and the sale of residential homes, investment properties, and vacation homes. Anne-Marie and her team also help vacation-rental owners explore whether converting their properties into long-term rentals may offer greater stability and fewer day-to-day demands.

With extensive local knowledge and a practical, straightforward approach, Anne-Marie remains committed to helping property owners protect their investments and make informed decisions about renting, managing, or selling their Central Florida homes.

Articles: 170