Seven Common Mistakes That Property Investors Make

As a company providing professional property management in Kissimmee, we have noticed seven common mistakes homeowners make while self-managing their own rental homes. These are things you want to avoid.

As a landlord entering the Kissimmee, Florida, market, you face unique challenges. Today, we’ll discuss 7 common mistakes homeowners make when self-managing their properties.

The Biggest Mistakes Long-Term Property Investors Make

1. Ignoring Tenant Notice Requirements

Tenants require a 24-hour notice before you enter their home for repairs or inspections. This is a legal requirement in Florida. In emergencies, you may waive this with the tenant’s permission. Schedule repairs around their availability, as it’s their home, even if you own it.

2. Mishandling Security Deposits

Never spend the security deposit. Keep it in a bank account for potential damages when tenants vacate. Some tenants leave homes in excellent condition, but if damage occurs, photograph it as evidence. Normal wear and tear, like minor wall marks, is acceptable under Florida law. Significant damage, like holes in walls or bleach stains on carpets, justifies using the deposit for repairs.

3. Poor Tenant Screening

Screen potential tenants thoroughly. Appearances can deceive; reliable tenants pay rent on time and maintain your property. Proper documentation ensures you select trustworthy renters.

As an investor who self-manages their property, get proper documentation before leasing to potential tenants. Don’t just rely on what they tell you. Look at pay stubs, check credit, and run background checks.

Ensuring your prospective tenants are responsible and trustworthy is vital to securing a successful tenant/homeowner relationship. We’ve met owners who leased to friends and family and sometimes strangers. Some tenants will not pay the rent if they think you’re a pushover, or you’ll give them extra time because this week’s paycheck went on car repairs or the concert they wanted to go to.

4. Using Generic Leases

Avoid generic leases from office supply stores. Hire an attorney to draft a lease specific to your property. Update it regularly, as landlord-tenant laws change. A current lease strengthens your position in court if disputes arise.

5. Skipping Move-In and Move-Out Inspections

Conduct move-in and move-out inspections with dated photos. Document the property’s condition before tenants move in and after they leave. These records prove damages, like a ruined kitchen counter or living room carpet, if disputes occur.

6. Neglecting Regular Inspections

Inspect your property at least once or twice a year. Regular checks reveal if tenants maintain the home. A tidy tenant may move out, leaving a less responsible one. Ongoing inspections protect your investment.

7. Accepting Cash Payments

Finally, do not accept cash for rent. Take a check, money order, or a wire transfer. Photocopy the payment method each month, and put the money directly into the bank account so you have a record.

You want to be able to prove what was paid. Don’t accept cash. Let them pay you online through the bank, check, or money order so you have a paper trail. If you allow them to pay cash and there’s a dispute, they can claim they paid you when they didn’t.

BONUS Property Investment Mistakes in Kissimmee, Florida

8. Skipping Market Research

Investors often buy properties without studying Kissimmee’s market. Understand local demand, rental rates, and growth areas. Analyze neighborhoods like Poinciana or Celebration. Use data from Zillow or local real estate boards. Visit properties and talk to agents. Knowledge prevents overpaying or choosing low-demand areas.

9. Paying Too Much

Overpaying reduces your returns. Compare recent sales in Kissimmee to set a fair price. Work with appraisers to confirm value and avoid emotional bidding wars. Negotiate firmly, using market data. If you are in the marketing to buy, here is our offer of homes for sale.

10. Misjudging Renovation Costs

Underestimating repairs drains budgets. Inspect properties thoroughly before buying. Hire contractors for estimates on Kissimmee homes, factoring in local labor rates. Budget 20% extra for surprises like plumbing issues. Accurate cost planning protects your investment.

11. Overlooking Cash Flow

Poor cash flow projections sink investments. Calculate rental income against expenses like mortgages, taxes, and maintenance. Kissimmee’s tourist-driven market fluctuates seasonally. Use conservative estimates for occupancy.

12. Neglecting Property Management

Mismanaging properties frustrates tenants. Hire a reliable Kissimmee property management company or dedicate time to handling tasks. Respond to tenant issues promptly. Maintain properties regularly. Good management retains tenants and boosts income.

13. Borrowing Too Much

Excessive loans strain finances. Limit debt to 70% of the property’s value. Calculate monthly payments against Kissimmee rental income. Maintain cash reserves for emergencies.

14. Ignoring Local Rules

Kissimmee has specific zoning and rental laws. Research long-term rental regulations. Consult city officials or attorneys. Comply with permitting requirements. If you decide to work with a property management company, then you don’t need to worry about these, as we handle the entire workload for you.

15. Lacking a Clear Plan

Unfocused strategies waste resources. Define your Kissimmee investment goals—long-term rentals or vacation properties? Set timelines and budgets. Stick to your plan, adjusting only with data. We recommend long-term rentals instead of short-term, but either way, you need to have a proper plan in place.

16. Following Hype Blindly

Chasing trends without research misleads investors. Investigate Kissimmee’s “hot” areas like West Kissimmee. Verify claims with sales data and rental demand. Talk to local experts. Grounded decisions outperform impulsive ones.

17. Forgetting Maintenance Costs

Ongoing repairs add up. Budget 1% of the property’s value annually for Kissimmee homes. Account for Florida’s humid climate, which causes mold or AC wear. Schedule regular inspections. Proactive maintenance prevents costly fixes.

Economic shifts impact rentals. Monitor Kissimmee’s tourism and job growth. Track unemployment rates and hotel occupancy. Adjust pricing or vacancy expectations. Staying informed prepares you for market changes. Read more: Why Vacancies Are Up and Tourism Is Slower in Orlando This Year.

19. Skimping on Insurance

Inadequate coverage risks losses. Secure landlord insurance for Kissimmee properties, including hurricane protection. Compare policies for comprehensive terms. Review coverage yearly. Proper insurance safeguards your investment.

20. Keeping Poor Records

Disorganized finances create problems. Track Kissimmee rental income, expenses, and repairs. Use software like QuickBooks. Store receipts and contracts. Accurate records simplify taxes and disputes.

If you need more ideas and support, don’t forget to conact us.

DO YOU NEED A PROPERTY MANAGER?

Partner up with the #1 property management company in the Orlando area. With over 30 years of experience we are your best choice.

Anne-Marie McCormack
Anne-Marie McCormack

Anne-Marie McCormack has been a Florida licensed Real Estate Broker since 1996. She has worked as a realtor in property management, rentals and sales in Kissimmee, Davenport, and Orlando, Florida since 1991.

She heads the team at McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes and has lots of experience with long-term and short-term rentals and sales. . Anne-Marie owned and operated a short-term-rental, property management company from 1994-2004. Since then McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes has focused on long-term rentals and sales of residential, investment homes and vacation homes also known as holiday lets.

Articles: 154

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *